Borrowed Water, a collaborative LP between Hainbach and My Panda Shall Fly, is a project of two distinct sides. The best way to discuss it, then, is to deal with these sides separately.
The first—a futuristic, public information film-esque set of joyful ambient tracks—recalls the optimism and clarity of the early 1970s. But there’s some grit provided in analogue tape decay; fizzes and screeches which show the other face of the era. The rumble of impending nuclear armageddon, the first awarenesses of climate change. These tracks are touted as “an alternate soundtrack to Douglas Trumbull’s Silent Running”—a description which, while apposite, does not incorporate the album’s earthliness.
The squeak of synthesisers on Borrowed Water is like an aviary. Natural sounds take flight amidst concrete and cavernous textures. This music is practically a guided tour of the Barbican centre. It's stolid, urban, colourless, but full of both light and life all the same. Brian Eno’s Apollo: Atmospheres and Soundtracks explored an extraterrestrial landscape, in total solitude, marked by an absence of life. Borrowed Water is its opposite—work that’s grounded, deeply terrestrial, and that bursts with pleasant chatter.
The second side announces itself with ‘The Half and the Whole’, a track which makes striking use of negative space. Compared the what’s come before, it is alarmingly placeless. The track seems to stutter in and out of existence like a dodgy transmission. It's the gasp of a server room trying to compile its information into something soul-shaped. The coldest and most barren track on the album, this heaves meekly as an iron lung. Masterful and memorable, this track provides outstanding contrast at the perfect time.
The turning point signalled by ‘The Half and the Whole’ continues through a fractious and frictional second side. For the duration of the side, there is no floor—in direct opposition to the first, everything is without shape, unstructured. Use of disintegrated tape is much more extensive and a feeling of decay-decline is muscled to the foreground. Tracks resolve to absence and silence, exhausting themselves in their playing. This side is described as “stretch[ing] out through other dimensions”, but it’s lonely enough to stretch from the perspective of Bowie’s Major Tom. The loneliness reaches its zenith in ‘Glory’, an otherworldly coda which rounds out the record in a smattering of bells and garbled speech.
The contrast that Borrowed Water establishes between its sides prevents either of their approaches becoming belaboured. The record is a balanced experience which explores just about as far as you’d ever want in two opposite directions. A very pleasing cocktail of the domestic and the alien.
Borrowed Water is available for purchase and streaming here.
Words by Andrew O’Keefe